The Omnivore's Dilemma is a fascinating read about the source of the food we eat today. It traces the history of industrial food (most of which comes from corn-- I learned more about corn than I ever thought I could know), organic food (most of which turns out to not seem so organic after all), pastoral food (not quite organic, but perhaps the more responsible local choice the consumer could make), and food which has been locally hunted and gathered.
Truth be told, this book took me a long time to read, mostly because most of the time I tried to sit down to read it, I ended up falling asleep instead. Most of the time a book puts me straight to sleep, I take it as a sign of truly dull reading matter. However, since having read this book, I feel like a much more interesting interested person, and I feel like I could maybe have a somewhat informed conversation with a farmer. I mean, most of my uncles are farmers, so I have conversations with farmers lots, but I feel like now I might be able to ask them some interesting questions about the work they do. Also, the little tidbit Pollan provides about where McDonald's meat comes from has made me (for the moment, at least) totally swear off of ever having another McDonald's hamburger again. Pollan informs us that most of the animals slaughtered to be used as McDonald's meat products comes from old dairy cows. Having been raised in a meat packing plant and seen my fair share of very nice and very not-so-nice meat, I personally know that the sight of meat from an old dairy cow inspires an innate disgust. Also, having been raised in a butcher shop, Pollan's descriptions and judgments towards kill floors (and the people who work on them) kind of wore thin with me. From the time I was four until I was about ten, I spent most of my free time watching the men work on the kill floor. I thought it was a fascinating process and I don't feel that I'm the least bit demented for it. I certainly never stooped towards animal cruelty, torturing kittens, or developed any other habits that he suggests that people who spend a lot of time on kill floors tend to develop. In fact, in the defense of kill floor workers (and observers), I personally cannot stand to see an animal suffering; it truly saddens me. And in response to the implications and comments that anyone who has seen a kill floor in action would have a hard time bringing themselves to eat meat again: for me, it reinforced my meat-eating habits. I had a better understanding of where meat came from and how it got from the pasture (or feedlot) to our table, and, from a very early age, I had a much clearer understanding of life and death than most other kids did. If anything, my time spent on the kill floor, reinforced what a natural thing eating meat is. And also, I never once saw any acts of unnecessary cruelty towards animals.
However, I don't want this review to be a mere diatribe about misrepresentations of kill floors. In Pollan's defense, kill floor descriptions comprise only a small part of the book, there are some descriptions of more humane kill operations (like the chicken slaughtering at the Polyface farm), and for all I know, perhaps my family's small meat packing plant was the exception, not the norm, where humane slaughtering practices were always observed. I am glad that I forced myself to finish this book through to the end because it gives me more to think about every time I choose something to eat for myself.
One last amusing point. Throughout the book, I noticed a favourite word that Pollan liked to use again and again: "boon". If I had a bottle of wine for every time Pollan used the word boon, it probably would have taken me a few more weeks to finish reading the book. He used it at least once per chapter, sometimes even twice!
Next book:
Moral Dilemma by Margaret Atwood